New

Published on:

January 3, 2025

Alankar Mishra

Blog |

Explore GST

Basics of GST

Section 54 of the Income Tax Act: Capital Gain Exemptions

Section 54 of Income Tax Act: Capital Gain Exemptions

In India, the Income Tax Act sets several provisions which help an individual or an entity to ease their tax burden. This said act provides several advantages but one of its most notable is not only the exemption of capital gain under Section 54 but this section is particularly meant for the cases of individuals and Hindu Undivided Families (HUF). This article has therefore provided written input on section 54 of the Income Tax Act, who are the beneficiaries, what benefits are conferred on them, what are the constraints of the section and how realistically the section is used.

What is Section 54 of the Income Tax Act?

According to the provisions in Section 54 of the Internal Revenue Services Code, it can be said that an LTCG will be exempt from taxation only where on the loss of the ownership of the residential house there is a gain that is used in the purchase or construction of another. Such provisions have been formulated to stimulate investments in housing and also reduce the tax burden on the owners.

Key Highlights of Section 54:

Eligible Taxpayers: Only Individuals and Hindu Undivided Families (HUF).

Under SAT: Only the residential properties are treated as long-term capital assets.

Exemption criteria: Disposal of such an asset after the prescribed minimum hold period.

Who is Eligible to Avail of the Exemption Under Section 54?

According to subsection 54 of the Income Tax Act, the benefit applies to Persons and Hindu Undivided Families (HUF). To avail of this exemption, the conditions given below have to be fulfilled:

Type of Asset Sold: The exemption is only applicable where the capital gains are derived from the sale of a house or flat which is classified as long-term capital assets.

Purpose of the Exemption: The proceeds from the sale have to be utilized for either of the following purposes:

‍To acquire new single-family residence within a prescribed period or

‍To build a new single-family residence.

Time Frame: The reinvestment must occur within the following timelines:

1. Buying Property: An asset can be sold by buying a new asset within 1 year or 2 years.

2. Building Property: The building of the property needs to be finished within 3 years after it was sold.

What House is Bought: The bought asset should qualify as a residence and be situated in India.

Use of Money: If the capital gain is not reinvested into the asset, it ought to be put in the Capital Gain Account Scheme before the target of filing an income tax return to avoid tax levy.

Requirements Claiming Exemption under Section 54

To qualify for the provisions set out in Section 54 various conditions must be satisfied:

Nature of the Asset:

The residential property in question must be sold to realize a capital gain.

The redistribution of asset class sold must be for the long term, that is it has been held for more than 24 months.

Reinvestment:

The taxpayer must within the set period provided:

Purchase: Between 1 year before or 2 years after a transfer has taken place.

Construction: For 3 years after the transfer has taken place.

The other requirement is that the new property acquired must also be located within India as of AY 2020-21.

Limit on the Number of Properties:

Until AY 2019-20, an exemption was provided only on the reinvestment of a single residential property.

However, from AY 2020-21, individuals who are taxpayers were allowed to claim exemptions on investment in at most two residential houses as long as the net gains were not more than ₹2 crores. This opportunity however can be taken advantage of only once in a lifetime.

Lock-in Period:

The three years are counted from the date of construction and acquisition of the property and after that, for some time the property will be disposed of. If disposed of, then the exemption will be cancelled and any capital gain will be taxed.

Quantum of Exemption under Section 54 of the IT Act

Under section 54, the exemption amount is the lower of:

Actual capital gains are obtained from the disposal of the old asset.

The value of new residential property which is purchased or constructed.

Detailed Examples for Better Understanding

Example 1: Exemption on Reinvestment in One Property

Scenario: Mr. A sold his residential property. He received sale consideration of ₹80 lakh for the property and thus, earned a long-term capital gain of ₹30 lakh on sale. He qualified as a resident, therefore, with the proceeds he sold his property, he purchased one more residential property worth ₹25 lakh, within the given period of such purchase.

Exemption: They are both limited to the amount of gain that arose from the sale which is ₹30 lakh or the amount which was spent on such reinvestment in the acquisition of new assets which is ₹25 lakh. Therefore there is an exemption of ₹25 lakh which means that the net chargeable gain after all the relief is given will be only ₹5 lakh considering the total deduction of assets from gain.

Example 2: Reinvestment in Two Properties

Scenario: Later, the sale proceeds were divided into two investments of ₹50 lakh each. She received proceeds of ₹1 crore as a capital gain. Mrs. B sells off her residential property which has a sale value of ₹1.2 crores.

Exemption: The reinvestment of 1 crore and the capital gain of 1 crore being equal in amount means that they are both chargeable to exemption.

Conditions Leading to Withdrawal of Exemption

The Exemption made under Section 54 may be revoked if:

‍The new property is sold off by the taxpayer within 3 years from the purchase/construction of the property.

‍The conditions relating to reinvestment are not fulfilled, that is to say, the taxpayer does not put back the gains made within the prescribed time limit.

‍In such scenarios, the capital gain that was exempt previously becomes taxable in the year when the new property is sold.

Tax Planning Opportunities Using Section 54

Anything related to Section 54 is invaluable for tax planning especially if an individual is interested in upgrading or expanding their real estate assets. Here are some useful practices:

Reinvestment within the period: make sure that disbursal of the reinvestment is scheduled within the periods stipulated.

Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS):

In case the capital gains are not immediately applied for reinvestment, the funds should be put in a Capital Gains Account Scheme to claim the relief.

These funds are to be utilized within the prescribed period for acquisition erection.

Maximize by investing in 2 Properties: For greater gains, use the one-time restriction on 2 properties where it can be invested perhaps in 2 Crores of limit.

Joint Ownership:

If the Property is held jointly then both co-owners share the right of claiming exemption under Section 54 as long as other conditions are satisfied.

Limitations and Drawbacks

Though there are great advantages offered under Section 54, a few limitations must be observed:

Restrictive Scope: The provision is confined to individuals and HUFs only, companies and other entities cannot claim the benefit.

Geographical Limitation: Reinvestment is to be made in properties which are within the territory of India.

Inflexibility with Commercial Properties: Under this section, the exemption is not eligible on account of gains arising from commercial properties.

Comparison with Other Relevant Sections

Section 54 vs Section 54F:

Regarding income concerned with the capital gain from the sale of the residential premises, section 54 is applicable while Section 54F comes in aid for long-term capital assets other than property.

Section 54 allows for the partial exemption of tax, However now when it comes to Section 54 F all sale proceeds being reinvested does allow for a 100 percent exemption.

Section 54 vs Section 54EC:

It is possible to claim an exemption from Section 54EC by purchasing specific bonds such as REC or NHAI however section 54 only allows this if the sale proceeds of the residential property are utilized to purchase another one.

In terms of a financial year, the maximum amount of investment that is allowed under Section 54E is ₹50 lakh.

Recent Amendments and Judicial Rulings

Amendment for More than One Asset:

As of AY 2020-2021, others can qualify too – provided, they adhere to certain conditions.

Key Judicial Precedents:

The Courts have upheld the claim of exemption of reinvestment even with a portion of that being financed by a housing loan.

In some cases, the benefit was even extended when the purchase was made out of unregistered agreements.

Practical Challenges in Claiming Section 54 Exemption

Documentation Requirements:

This needs to be undertaken: Sale proceeds and purchase contracts as well as the source of proof of the reinvestment must be preserved.

Utilisation of CGAS:

Any deposits which are made into any of the accounts are capital gains accounts and should be used exclusively for the purpose for which they were intended, and noncompliance could result in the exemption being revoked.

Conclusion

Section 54 of the Income Tax Act provides some relief for individuals and HUFs who are looking to reinvest their capital gains rather than paying a CGT on them However, it is crucial to stay alert as you also have to fulfill the limitations as beat the deadlines and provide relevant documentation to prevent complications later on.

Look for a good and reliable tax planner tax adviser or chartered accountant for any help you may need in filing or even christ planning your taxes. This way, you will not only be able to avail of section 54 in the maximum possible manner but also comply with the law.

FAQs

1. Who is eligible to claim an exemption under Section 54 of the Income Tax Act?

In Clause 54 it is laid down that the individuals and Hindu undivided families who are not individuals are also allowed to sell the long-term self-residential house and use the money so received to purchase another residential house.

2. What is the time limit for reinvestment to claim exemption under Section 54?

The reinvestment must be carried out within 1 year before, or 2 years succeeding the date of reinstatement sale of the purchased property, or within a window of 3 years succeeding the sales if a property is being constructed.

3. Can I claim Section 54 benefits for reinvestment in two properties?

Reinvestment in two residential properties is permissible for AY 2020-21 and onwards as long as the capital gains do not go beyond ₹2 crore. Please note however that this option can be exercised only once during a lifetime.

4. What happens if the new property is sold within 3 years?

If the newly constructed house is transferred to another owner within three years of its acquisition or construction, the relief granted under section 54 shall stand revoked and the capital gains so exempted, become taxable.

5. Can the exemption be claimed if the reinvestment is funded partially by a loan?

Thus, in case an area is abandoned which closely resembles a loan, even in such cases the taxpayer shall qualify for this exemption. It will be noticed, however, that the law contains a provision which states that the conditions of the reinvestment must be fulfilled.

6. Is it mandatory to reinvest the entire sale proceeds to claim an exemption under Section 54?

This conclusion is wrong as this concerns only the portion which is covered by a tax on the profit which has to be retained. In that situation, the amount of exemption that can be claimed is either the amount of capital gain on the net sale proceeds or the amount of reinvestment not exceeding their lower amount.

7. What is the deduction under Section 54?

Deductions under section 54 as per the Income Tax Act, allow a taxpayer to escape the burden of long-term capital gain tax on the sale of a residential house which qualifies if the capital gain has been realized and was used in purchasing or constructing a new residential house within the specific time frame.

‍