Five Years of GST : Triumphs and Laments

GST, or the Goods and Services Tax, was implemented in India on July 1, 2017, replacing a complex and multi-layered indirect tax system. The implementation of GST was seen as a major reform in the Indian tax system, aimed at simplifying the tax structure, reducing tax evasion, and increasing tax compliance.

Here are some of the triumphs and laments of the first five years of GST:

Triumphs:

1. Simplification of the tax structure: The implementation of GST has simplified the tax structure by replacing a multi-layered tax system with a single tax system. This has made it easier for businesses to comply with tax regulations and has reduced the burden of tax compliance.

2. Increased tax revenue: The implementation of GST has led to an increase in tax revenue for the government. This is due to increased tax compliance, reduced tax evasion, and the expansion of the tax base.

3. Removal of cascading effect: GST has eliminated the cascading effect of taxes, where taxes are levied on top of taxes. This has led to a reduction in the cost of goods and services, making them more affordable for consumers.

4. Improved logistics and supply chain: The implementation of GST has led to the creation of a unified national market, which has improved logistics and supply chain efficiency. This has reduced the cost of transportation and has made it easier for businesses to operate across different states.

5. Increased foreign investment: The implementation of GST has made India a more attractive destination for foreign investment by creating a stable and predictable tax regime.

Laments:

1. Technical glitches in the GST portal: The GST portal, which is used for tax filings and compliance, has faced several technical glitches since its implementation. This has led to delays in tax filings and compliance and has caused frustration among taxpayers.

2. Complex tax structure: While GST has simplified the tax structure, it is still a complex tax system with multiple tax rates and exemptions. This has led to confusion and uncertainty among taxpayers and has increased compliance costs.

3. Compliance burden: The compliance burden of GST is high, especially for small businesses. This is due to the requirement to file multiple returns and maintain detailed records.

4. Resistance to change: The implementation of GST has faced resistance from some sections of the business community who are resistant to change. This has led to protests and strikes in some parts of the country.

5. Inflationary pressures: In the short term, the implementation of GST has led to inflationary pressures, as businesses adjust to the new tax system. This has led to a temporary increase in the cost of goods and services, which has affected consumers.

6. Delay in refunds: One of the major concerns for businesses under the GST regime has been the delay in getting refunds for input tax credit. This has caused cash flow issues for businesses, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises.

7. Multiple tax rates: The GST system in India has multiple tax rates, which has led to confusion among taxpayers. The multiple rates have also made it difficult for businesses to make decisions on pricing and product lines.

8. Issues with the anti-profiteering mechanism: The anti-profiteering mechanism, which was introduced to ensure that businesses pass on the benefits of lower taxes to consumers, has faced several issues. There have been concerns about the methodology used to calculate the benefits passed on to consumers, and the slow pace of investigations and action against businesses found guilty of not passing on the benefits.

9. Lack of clarity on certain issues: There are still several issues that remain unclear under the GST regime, including the treatment of discounts, the classification of certain goods and services, and the applicability of tax on certain transactions. This lack of clarity has caused confusion among taxpayers and has led to disputes between businesses and tax authorities.

10. Need for continuous updates: The GST system requires continuous updates and changes, which can create uncertainty for businesses. Frequent changes to the tax rates, exemptions, and compliance requirements can make it difficult for businesses to plan and manage their operations effectively.

‍

FAQs

1. What are the benefits of GST implementation in India?

GST has simplified the tax structure by replacing multiple indirect taxes with a single tax, making compliance easier for businesses.
It has reduced the cascading effect of taxes, leading to a decrease in the overall tax burden for businesses.
The implementation of GST has helped to increase the revenue base for the government, which can be used for public welfare schemes.

2. How has GST impacted the prices of goods and services?

The impact of GST on prices has been mixed, with some goods and services becoming cheaper, while others have become more expensive.
The reduction in tax rates for goods such as consumer durables, and services such as restaurants, has led to a decrease in prices.
However, the increase in tax rates for certain goods, such as mobile phones, has led to an increase in prices.

3. What are the challenges faced by businesses under the GST regime?

The major challenges faced by businesses under the GST regime include compliance issues, such as filing returns and claiming input tax credit.
Another major challenge is the delay in refunds for input tax credit, which has caused cash flow issues for businesses.
The multiple tax rates and lack of clarity on certain issues have also led to confusion and difficulties in compliance for businesses.

4. How has GST impacted the economy of India?

GST has had a positive impact on the economy of India by simplifying the tax structure and increasing the tax base.
It has also helped to improve the ease of doing business in India by reducing compliance requirements and streamlining the tax system.
The implementation of GST has also helped to increase government revenue, which can be used for public welfare schemes and infrastructure development.

5. What is the future of GST in India?

The future of GST in India looks promising, as the government continues to work towards streamlining the tax structure and reducing compliance requirements.
The GST Council has been working towards simplifying the tax structure further, and the implementation of a single tax rate system may be considered in the future.
However, there are still several issues that need to be addressed, such as the delay in refunds and the lack of clarity on certain issues.

6. How has GST impacted the logistics and transportation sector in India?

GST has brought in uniformity and eliminated multiple taxes, reducing the transit time and costs for the transportation and logistics sector.
The introduction of e-way bill has also helped in streamlining the movement of goods and reducing the transit time.
The removal of state-level checkpoints and the reduction of documentation requirements have further helped in improving the efficiency of the logistics sector.

7. What are the concerns regarding GST implementation in India?

One of the major concerns regarding GST implementation in India is the complexity of the tax structure, with multiple tax rates and compliance requirements.
Another concern is the delay in refunds for input tax credit, which has caused cash flow issues for businesses.
The lack of clarity on certain issues, such as the treatment of discounts and the applicability of GST on e-commerce transactions, has also led to confusion and difficulties in compliance for businesses.

8. How has GST impacted the small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in India?

GST has had a mixed impact on the SMEs in India, with some businesses benefiting from the simplified tax structure, while others facing challenges in compliance.
The introduction of the composition scheme for SMEs with a turnover of up to Rs. 1.5 crore has helped in reducing the compliance requirements for small businesses.
However, the delay in refunds and the complexity of the tax structure has caused difficulties for some SMEs.

9. What are the expectations from the government regarding GST in the future?

The government is expected to address the concerns regarding the delay in refunds and the complexity of the tax structure.
The GST Council may consider simplifying the tax structure further by introducing a single tax rate system.
The government is also expected to continue working towards improving compliance requirements and reducing the burden on businesses.