GST on Real Estate Joint Development Agreements (JDA): Key Insights and Implications

The real estate industry is one of the cornerstones of India's economy. Among different business models in the real estate industry, Joint Development Agreements (JDA) have become extremely popular. In a standard JDA, the owner of land enters into an agreement with a developer or builder to develop real estate ventures. Rather than selling the land in full, the landowner permits the developer to build apartments or commercial areas, and the landowner is paid a portion of the developed property or income.

Though this model works to the advantage of both parties, it also carries intricate tax implications, particularly in the regime of the Goods and Services Tax (GST). Developers, landowners and even purchasers need to understand how GST works under JDAs to prevent future tax issues and adhere to compliance.

GST and Joint Development Agreements: A Closer Look

Under GST, construction services would be a taxable supply. As far as JDAs are concerned, GST implications occur at several stages, mostly due to the fact that there is a supply of goods and services between the landowner and the developer.

Major GST Provisions Affecting JDAs

Supply from Developer to Landowner:

The developer builds property on the landowner's land and provides the landowner with part of the developed property (such as apartments or shops). GST is charged on the value of the construction services rendered by the developer to the landowner. The share of the landowner is considered.

Supply to Buyers:

When the builder is selling the units to the prospective buyers in advance of completion, GST is levied at prevailing rates (usually 5% without Input Tax Credit on residential property, and 1% for affordable housing scheme).

Time for Payment of GST:

According to GST rules, the tax payment liability occurs when possession or the right in the constructed property is transferred to the landowner.

Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM):

In some instances, including when land development rights are transferred by the landowner, RCM provisions can be applicable, whereby the developer must pay GST under reverse charge.

Suggested Read:GST on Services Exported but Consideration Not Received: What You Should Know

Benefits of JDAs under GST

Less Cash Outflow Immediately:

JDAs enable developers to purchase land without significant upfront payments. Landowners receive a proportionate interest in the developed property, meaning that there is no significant initial cash transaction that is subject to GST on the transfer of land.

Simplified Tax Treatment:

The GST system has given more explicit tax guidelines to JDAs, lessening the previous uncertainty under the VAT and Service Tax systems. This assists landowners as well as developers in planning their tax expenses more effectively.

Availability of Input Tax Credit (ITC) (Limited):

Developers can obtain ITC on inputs utilized for commercial property. Although ITC is limited to residential developments under the 5% slab, it continues to be available for commercial developments.

‍Structured Compliance:

The GST regime has introduced transparency and accountability by way of mandatory invoicing, e-way bills, and frequent return filing, which is advantageous to all stakeholders in the longer term.

Disadvantages and Challenges of JDAs under GST

GST on Transfer of Development Rights (TDR):

In the past, there was uncertainty on GST applicability on TDR. While there are exemptions available now up to the value of residential apartments disposed of prior to completion, complexity in calculation and compliance still exists, particularly for developers.

Complexities in Valuation:

The taxable value of services rendered by the developer to the owner of the land may be difficult to determine, particularly when market rates change. Misvaluation may attract penalties and lawsuits.

Cash Flow Pressure Owing to Timing of Payment of GST:

Developers would have to pay GST on the landowner's component even before they take money from customers. This can cause cash flow problems, especially during the delay or market slowdowns in projects.

Compliance Burden:

JDAs involve several GST registrations, paperwork, and cautious tax planning in order to ensure that both landowners and developers comply with their requirements. Non-compliance, albeit unwitting, would draw interest and penalties.

‍Conclusion

Joint Development Agreements are a viable option in the real estate sector, particularly when landowners are willing to accept a percentage of the developed property rather than a sale. GST added certainty to JDAs by harmonizing tax regulations, although compliance and valuation issues continue to face challenges. Developers and landowners need to remain vigilant and plan ahead to prevent legal issues. With effective planning, JDAs can continue to prove beneficial to all the parties concerned while remaining compliant with tax norms.

FAQs

Is GST chargeable on the transfer of land under a Joint Development Agreement?

No, GST is not chargeable on the transfer or sale of land since the sale of land is out of the purview of GST.

When should the developer pay GST on the share of the landowner in a JDA?

GST is chargeable when possession or rights in the developed property are transferred to the landowner.

Can the developer take Input Tax Credit (ITC) on a JDA project?

Commercial projects are eligible for ITC, but it is curbed for residential projects where the developer has chosen to pay the 5% GST rate.

Is GST to be paid by the landowner in a Joint Development Agreement?

Typically, the landowner is assigning the development rights to the developer. GST on this assignment can be passed on to the developer under the reverse charge mechanism.

Are JDAs beneficial for small developers?

Yes, JDAs can help small developers acquire land without immediate cash payments, though they must carefully handle GST compliance to avoid tax issues.

‍